Creamed Honey Flavors: A Guide to Every Variety We Make

We started with Original. One flavor, one ingredient, and a lot of faith that people would appreciate a really good jar of creamed honey.

They did. And then they started asking questions. What about cinnamon? What about blueberry? What would this taste like with maple? That is how ten flavors happened.

Every variety in our creamed honey lineup starts from the same foundation: small-batch raw honey, sourced from local apiaries and processed at room temperature into that smooth, spreadable consistency we are known for. What changes is what goes alongside it — natural flavors that complement the honey rather than compete with it. We should note that due to producing our creamed honey in small batches, the colors can vary slightly from batch to batch. Don’t worry! Nothing changed, the color of our raw honey varies and that will effect the color of the finished creamed honey.

Here is a guide to every flavor we make and what to do with each one.

Original

This is where we started, and it remains the one we come back to most. Pure creamed honey, nothing added. The flavor reflects the raw wildflower/clover/soybean honey underneath — complex, warm, with a finish that liquid honey does not always deliver in quite the same way. If you have never tried creamed honey before, start here.

Best on: warm toast, fresh biscuits, stirred into coffee or tea.

Cinnamon

Our most popular flavored variety, and it is easy to understand why. Warm, familiar, lightly spiced — it hits every note that makes a morning feel good. The cinnamon is present without being sharp, which means it works on anything you would normally put plain creamed honey on. Made with Saigon cinnamon.

Best on: toast, oatmeal, apple slices, warm biscuits. Excellent stirred into coffee.

Blueberry

Bright and fruity with a natural sweetness that layers beautifully over the honey base. This one works as well on a cheese board as it does on a breakfast table. Made with 100% fruit powder.

Best on: yogurt, pancakes, biscuits, tea. Pairs well with brie or cream cheese.

Peach

Summer in a jar. The peach flavor is natural and not overly sweet — it tastes like fruit, not candy. A favorite among people who prefer a lighter, more delicate flavor profile. Made with 100% fruit powder.

Best on: toast with butter, stirred into yogurt, alongside soft cheeses.

Lemon

Bright, tart, and refreshing in a way that most honey-based products are not. The lemon cuts through the richness of the honey and makes this one feel noticeably lighter than the others. Made with 100% fruit powder.

Best on: scones, biscuits, stirred into hot tea. Excellent paired with goat cheese.

Strawberry

Sweet and familiar, with a flavor that leans toward fresh strawberries rather than jam or candy. This is one of our most popular gift choices because it appeals to almost everyone, including people who do not usually gravitate toward flavored honey. Made with 100% fruit powder.

Best on: toast, waffles, biscuits, stirred into yogurt or oatmeal.

Raspberry

More tart than Strawberry, with a slightly deeper fruit flavor. The tartness of the raspberry balances the sweetness of the honey in a way that makes this one feel surprisingly complex for a simple spread. Made with 100% fruit powder.

Best on: toast with cream cheese, yogurt, charcuterie boards with sharp cheeses.

Blackberry

Rich and slightly earthy, with a deeper berry flavor than Raspberry or Blueberry. This one tends to appeal to people who prefer bolder flavors — it has a little more presence than the lighter fruit varieties. Made with 100% fruit powder.

Best on: toast, biscuits, stirred into oatmeal. Pairs well with aged cheeses.

Maple

Two natural sweeteners that turn out to complement each other beautifully. The maple adds a warm, caramel-adjacent depth to the honey without making it cloying. A favorite in fall and winter, and a natural fit for anyone who already reaches for maple syrup in the morning. Made with maple extract.

Best on: oatmeal, pancakes, waffles, stirred into coffee. Also excellent on sweet potato.

Caramel

Warm, rich, and indulgent in the best way. The caramel flavor adds a buttery sweetness that makes this one feel like a treat — though it is just as good on a plain piece of toast as anywhere else. Made with caramel extract.

Best on: toast, biscuits, apple slices. Also works as a topping for vanilla yogurt.

How to Choose

If you are buying your first jar, Original is the right starting point. It gives you the clearest sense of what our creamed honey tastes like before the flavors come into the picture.

If you want to explore several flavors without committing to a full jar of each, our Creamed Honey Flight is a great option — a curated sampler of 5 of our best selling flavors in one box, perfect for finding your favorite before going all in.

If you are shopping for someone else, our Pantry Pack lets you build a completely custom assortment of any flavors you choose. It is one of our most popular gifts, and it works for almost any occasion — birthdays, hostess gifts, teacher appreciation, the holidays, or just because.

Browse all ten flavors and find your new favorite in our Creamed Honey collection at natesnectarandmore.com.

Join our newsletter for recipes, new product announcements, and updates from our family in DeGraff, Ohio.