Creamed Honey Butter: The 2-Ingredient Spread Your Bread Has Been Waiting For

Some recipes require technique, patience, and a list of ingredients that sends you to three different stores. This is not one of those recipes. Creamed honey butter takes five minutes, uses two ingredients, and produces something so good on a warm biscuit that you will wonder why you ever reached for plain butter in the first place.

It is also one of those things that looks like you put in more effort than you did — which makes it useful for brunches, holiday tables, or any morning when you want breakfast to feel like more than a routine.

What You Need

 

Cinnamon Creamed Honey Butter ———————————————————— Makes: approximately ½ cup  |  Prep time: 5 minutes  |  Chill time: 30 minutes (optional)   Ingredients: 4 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened to room temperature 2 tablespoons Nate’s Nectar Cinnamon Creamed Honey   Instructions: 1. Make sure your butter is fully softened. It should yield easily when pressed — not melted, just soft. 2. Add the softened butter and creamed honey to a small bowl. 3. Mix together with a fork or small spatula until fully combined and smooth. The creamed honey will incorporate easily into soft butter. 4. Taste and adjust. If you want more honey flavor, add another half tablespoon. 5. Serve immediately at room temperature, or roll into a log using plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 minutes to slice cleanly.   Storage: Keep covered in the refrigerator for up to two weeks. Bring to room temperature before serving.

 

How to Serve It

The obvious answer is warm biscuits, and the obvious answer is correct. A fresh biscuit straight from the oven with a generous pat of cinnamon honey butter melting into it is one of those simple things that is genuinely hard to improve on. The cinnamon in the honey and the richness of the butter work together in a way that makes the biscuit taste like you put significantly more effort into it than you did.

Toast is another natural landing spot. The butter spreads easily straight from the fridge once it has softened slightly, and a thick layer on toasted sourdough or whole grain bread makes a breakfast worth sitting down for.

Cornbread is worth mentioning specifically. Honey butter on cornbread is a classic combination, and the cinnamon variety adds a warmth that plays particularly well against a slightly sweet cornbread. If you are making cornbread for a gathering and want something to set it apart, a small dish of this butter alongside it is all you need.

For something a little less expected, try it on a roasted sweet potato. Split the potato, let it cool slightly, and add a spoonful while it is still warm. The cinnamon and honey pull out the natural sweetness of the potato in a way that makes it feel more like a treat than a side dish.

Variations Worth Trying

Once you have the base recipe, the variations follow naturally. Any creamed honey flavor works — the technique is identical, and the only thing that changes is what ends up on your plate.

Maple Creamed Honey butter is the one to make for pancakes and waffles. The maple flavor is already present in the honey, which means you get a butter that tastes like maple syrup without the pour — it melts into the pancake as you eat rather than pooling on the plate. If you regularly make pancakes on the weekend, this version is worth keeping in the refrigerator as a standing item.

Blueberry Creamed Honey butter skews sweeter and more fruit-forward, which makes it a good match for neutral breads and plain scones where the flavor of the butter can be the main event. It is also a good option for a brunch spread where you want something that looks a little different next to the standard butter dish.

For any variation, the ratio stays the same: two tablespoons of creamed honey to four tablespoons of softened butter. Adjust slightly to taste once you have mixed it — some flavors carry more sweetness than others and you may want to dial it up or back depending on what you are serving it with.

A Note on the Honey

The reason creamed honey works so well in this recipe — better than liquid honey — is the texture. Liquid honey does not incorporate evenly into cold butter and tends to separate as it sits. Creamed honey blends cleanly because its consistency is already close to what you are mixing it into. The result is a smooth, uniform spread that holds together whether you serve it immediately or refrigerate it for later.

It is a small difference in ingredients that makes a meaningful difference in the result. Two tablespoons of the right honey is all it takes.

 

Shop Cinnamon, Maple, Blueberry, and all ten creamed honey flavors at natesnectarandmore.com. Not sure which to try first? The Creamed Honey Flight lets you sample several varieties before committing to a full jar.

 

Join our newsletter for recipes, farm updates, and new products from our family in DeGraff, Ohio.